京都大学大学院アジア・アフリカ地域研究研究科 COSER Center for On-Site Education and Research 附属次世代型アジア・アフリカ教育研究センター
京都大学大学院アジア・アフリカ地域研究研究科
フィールドワーク・レポート

Opposing Displacements in Jakarta/Study on Kampung Kirai in Cipete

Building of Mass Rapid Transit Station in Cipete Raya, Jakarta.

Research Background

 On April 2019, the first Indonesian Mass-Rapid Transit (MRT) opened commercially to the public in Jakarta. However, it was estimated that thousands of households living along the elevated train track and subway stations were displaced through 2012-2017.

Research Purpose

 This article aims to study evictions in Jakarta, where the severity of mega-displacement mainly attributed to infrastructure projects (Jakarta Legal Aid, 2016, 2017, 2018). It will investigate on Kampung Kirai which is located in the same area as the elevated MRT station Cipete Raya. The study shows that MRT project could potentially lead to gentrification, a process where people with higher socio-economic status capitalise the low property value since transit access is found to have positive effects on prices of residential properties and apartment rents (Bowes and Ihlanfeldt, 2001).

“Save Kirai! Ready for Legal Recourse!” and “You have entered area of legally defected M10-M11 certificate!” among others can be found in an alley of Kirai, Cipete.

Results

 In Kampung Kirai, Cipete Raya, residents were constantly under threats of being evicted by a private developer who aims to transform their neighbourhood into a lucrative apartment building complex close to the MRT station. The residents in Kirai had lived for at least three generations, dating back during the colonial era. The area was inherited by three prominent Betawian Nyai (Ladies) who relied on the administrative management of the space to their mandor (foreman). At that time, it was the common practice for women not to be able to read and write and to rely on their property management to men. Hence, it was the foreman who held the colonial land certificate, known as eigmond verponding, and paid the land tax on behalf of the Ladies regularly.
 During 1960s, Indonesian government established the Agrarian Law Constitution which encourages people to convert their verponding to the new land certificate with their resident card as a requirement. However, the lack of information and the ability to read had prevented the Ladies from acquiring the new land certificate. They continued to give money to their foreman to pay land taxes. It was believed that the money given to the foreman was corrupted by his family to convert the verponding into the new land certificate, Sertifikat Hak Milik (SHM) 10 and SHM 11. Many had suspected the involvement of private developer Lippo Group, who already acquired land close to the area and built Kemang Village, for its involvement in this counterfeit. At the same time, both the ladies and the foreman’s family had sold most of their land to urban migrants who came to Jakarta.
 Today, approximately 355 households lived in 6.5 hectares of Kampung Kirai. Over the years, they could never be able to acquire any land right from the local government, even when they held resident card, paid land taxes, bills and voted during elections. Throughout the MRT development process, goons had aggressively threated the residents with weapons and violence to evict them. Opposing to this, the residents had launched legal investigations, heightened security and created murals depicting their protests in their kampung.
 Their investigation uncovered many suspicious irregularities in the ownership of SHM 10 and SHM 1. For example, both certificates were once mortgaged to Bank Negara Indonesia (BNI) by the foreman’s family, yet when the family was unable to pay the debt, the local government issued new certificates for them, accepting lost as the main reason. Another peculiarity was found in the ownership of the certificate. It was stated that the landowners are five of the foreman’s children, however, the certificate was issued long after the foreman’s children were all deceased. Lastly, the land right was signed by a person whose position is not in charge of issuing certificates in the National Land Agency.

Plans for Further Research

 As seen in Kampung Kirai, transport systems may cause gentrification as they alter the social and spatial distribution of accessibility benefits throughout the city. I believe further studies are required to expand the analysis, specifically on the act of violence and policing in evictions cases, and urban activism led by the poor. At last, although land certificate manipulation encompassing bribery to the local government, residents and local public figures is uncommon in Indonesian, it is enticing to investigate further how the pattern is structured and ran on everyday life, as studies on this detail are rare.

References

【1】Bowes and Ihlafeldt, 2001. Identifying the impact of rail transit stations on residential property values. Journal of Urban Economics. 50(1), p1-25.
【2】Jakarta Legal Aid. 2016. Seperti Puing: Laporan Penggusuran Paksa di Wiliyah DKI Jakarta. Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Jakarta, Jakarta.
【3】---2017. Mengais di Pusara Janji: Laporan Penggusuran Paksa di Wiliyah DKI Jakarta. Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Jakarta, Jakarta.
【4】---2018. Masih Ada: Laporan Penggusuran Paksa di Wiliyah DKI Jakarta. Lembaga Bantuan Hukum Jakarta, Jakarta.

  • レポート:Ruriana Nafilah Anggraini(Year of enrollment: AY2018)
  • 派遣先国:Indonesia
  • 渡航期間:August 10th, 2018 to February 16th, 2019
  • キーワード:Jakarta, eviction, infrastructure development, urban activism

関連するフィールドワーク・レポート

狭間の戦争認識

対象とする問題の概要  戦争モニュメントや戦争を扱った博物館というのは、世界中に存在する。それらは、概して加害/被害の二項対立構造を伴っている。よって、加害者でも、それに対応する被害者でもない者たちの「戦争」経験が看過されてきたのではないだ…

ウガンダにおける人口増加に伴う都市空間の形成と土地利用の変容

対象とする問題の概要  サハラ以南アフリカは現在、世界で人口が最も増加している地域である。アフリカの都市部では、農村から都市への人口移動によって爆発的に人口が増加し、その人口増加に対応した居住環境や交通、教育、衛生など多くのインフラ整備が課…

セントラル・カラハリ・サンの子ども社会への近代教育の影響――ノンフォーマル教育の事例から――

対象とする問題の概要  1977年より、ボツワナ政府は、民主主義、発展、自立、統一を教育理念に掲げてきた。1970年代中頃まで狩猟採集を生活の基盤としていたサンの社会は、政府の定住化政策によって、管理、教育、訓練の対象となってきた。こうした…

在タイ日本人コミュニティの分節とホスト社会との交渉/チェンマイ、シラチャ、バンコクを事例に

対象とする問題の概要  2017年現在、在タイ日本人の数は7万人を超え、これは米国、中国、豪州に次ぐ規模である 。タイでは、1980年代後半から日系企業の進出が相次ぎ、日本人駐在員が増加している。加えて1990年代以降は日本経済の低迷や生活…